How To Choose A Midi Controller That Works For You?

You are currently viewing How To Choose A Midi Controller That Works For You?

Unlock Your Musical Journey: Exploring the Must-Have Features of MIDI Keyboard Controllers

That feeling of sitting down at a piano and letting your fingers dance across the keys to create beautiful music is magical.

Now imagine having that expressive playing power anywhere – bedroom, studio, stage – with the perfect MIDI keyboard.

Choosing the right MIDI keyboard controller with weighted hammer action and expressive controls can make you feel like a concert pianist, even if producing electronic beats.

Prioritizing key feel and connectivity for your workflow unlocks seamless musical creativity.

With so many MIDI keyboard options on the market, how do you pick the right one?

Let’s dive in and explore the key factors like keybed, controls, connectivity, portability, and budget to consider when purchasing a MIDI controller keyboard for home music production.

How Many Keys Should A Home MIDI Keyboard Have?

Image comparing MIDI keyboard controllers with different key counts, helping readers determine the ideal key count for their home music setup

The number of keys and octave range is one of the first decisions to make when choosing a home MIDI keyboard.

Get the Full Piano Range with 88 Keys

Full 88-key keyboards provide the complete span of a traditional piano, giving you all the notes from the lowest A to the highest C.

This gives you maximum range for playing piano parts and recording MIDI data across the entire spectrum.

61 or 76 Keys Offer Lots of Range in Less Space

However, 61-key and 76-key keyboards offering 5 or 6 octaves may still provide sufficient range for many home studio needs while taking up less space.

49 Keys: A Nice Middle Ground for Home Use

For more limited spaces and portability, 49-key models with 4 octaves present a nice middle ground, giving you a decent playing range from F below middle C to C above middle C.

You can play chords and melodies comfortably in different octaves.

Ultra-Portable 25-Key MIDI Keyboards

If space is at a premium, mini 25-key MIDI keyboards with just 2 octaves may allow you to fit into a backpack or small desk.

The 25-key range reaches from F below middle C up 2 octaves to F above middle C.

This gives you some options for playing and recording melodies, basslines, and simple chords, though reaching full piano voicings will be difficult.

The greater the number of keys and octave range, the more flexibility and freedom you’ll have to play parts and record MIDI data across a wider spectrum.

But if your main goal is melody and bass line recording or triggering samples and loops, a 25- or 49-key model may provide the perfect balance of portability and function.

Consider the types of instruments and parts you want to record and how much space you have available before deciding on the best key range.

Should I Get Weighted Or Synth Action Keys?

Image depicting a comparison between weighted and synth action keys on MIDI keyboard controllers, assisting readers in making an informed choice

The feel and response of the keyboard keys themselves is another prime consideration.

Hammer Action Weighted Keys Feel Just Like Piano

Weighted hammer action keys aim to mimic the piano-like feel of acoustic pianos by using small weighted hammers inside the unit.

When you press down, you feel the hammers strike the keys to provide familiar resistance and bounce back.

This weighted movement helps build finger strength and dexterity that translates to real piano playing.

The weighted touch also facilitates more dynamic and expressive playing as you can control volume and articulation based on your striking force.

Light Synth Action Enables Rapid Play

On the other hand, synth action keys have a lighter, shallower action optimized for fast playing often needed for synthesizer and organ parts.

Rather than weighted hammers, synth action uses springs or membranes inside the key mechanism.

This allows rapid, repeated notes since the keys return to resting position very quickly after striking.

Synth action also requires less finger exertion, facilitating quick passages and higher tempos.

The tradeoff is that ultra-light synth action does not recreate the authentic piano touch.

Semi-Weighted Keys: A Middle Ground

In between, some keyboards provide semi-weighted action.

The keys have some substance and resistance compared to synth action but are not fully weighted like piano hammers.

This middle ground gives a more realistic dynamic response while still allowing moderately fast playing.

Consider the types of instruments and parts you want to play, as well as your long-term goals as a keyboardist.

Weighted hammer action excels for piano parts and developing skills that translate to real pianos.

But synth action allows ultra-fast play for synthesizers and organs.

Choose the key action that best fits your style and goals.

Is Velocity And Aftertouch Sensitivity Necessary?

Image illustrating the concept of velocity and aftertouch sensitivity on MIDI keyboard controllers, helping readers grasp their importance for expressive play

Beyond the weight and action of the keys, also evaluate the velocity and aftertouch sensitivity.

Velocity Sensitivity Captures Your Playing Dynamics

Velocity sensitivity enables the keyboard to detect not just which notes you play but the speed and force with which you strike the keys.

Essentially, it registers the dynamics of your playing just like an acoustic piano.

When you play harder, the MIDI note velocities will be higher.

When you play softly, the velocities are lower.

This velocity data gets transmitted along with the MIDI note information to drive virtual instrument articulations and tonal changes.

Dynamic playing allows for musical phrasing, accents, and expression.

Aftertouch Adds Expressive Control

Similarly, aftertouch records pressure applied to the keys even after the initial strike.

By pressing down or wiggle fingers on the sustained keys, you can add modulation, pitch bends, vibrato and other expressive elements.

Both velocity and aftertouch bring your virtual instrument performances to life by mirroring the nuanced articulation of an acoustic piano performance.

These dynamics excellently control virtual synthesizers, samplers, string sections, and other software instruments.

Bottom line – velocity and aftertouch allow your playing to sound more human and emotional rather than robotic and sterile.

These should be considered standard requirements for any contemporary MIDI keyboard.

What Extra Controls Should My MIDI Keyboard Have?

Image depicting a MIDI keyboard controller with various extra controls, emphasizing their importance in music production and creativity

The keys themselves form the core playing interface, but most MIDI keyboards integrate extra controls like wheels, knobs, buttons, pads, and faders.

This unlocks creative options by putting parameters and effects right at your fingertips.

Pitch & Modulation Wheels Add Expression

For example, pitch bend and modulation wheels are common for bending notes, adding vibrato, and altering sounds in real time during performance.

Buttons allow quick access to change presets, activate arpeggios, and more.

Faders help control levels and mixing.

Knobs for Dynamic Sound Morphing

Rotary knobs provide dynamic real-time sound modification as you turn through various parameter values.

Knobs often control filter cutoffs, envelope attack/release, oscillator waveforms, and other sound-shaping options.

Drum Pads & Step Sequencers for Beats

Some keyboards incorporate 16 or more velocity-sensitive drum pads for playing rhythms and samples.

Higher-end models may add step sequencers, enabling you to program beats and grooves.

Evaluate what you want to achieve, and choose a keyboard with the controls that suit your style and setup best.

For live playing, wheels and knobs facilitate real-time sound tweaking and morphing.

Knobs also excel for producing as you can easily map them to software instrument and effect parameters.

Those focused on beat making will benefit from velocity-sensitive pads and step sequencing.

Too many extraneous controls can clutter the interface, but having the right options transforms your keyboard from a simple input device to an instrument with organic expression.

What Connectivity Options Do I Need?

Image illustrating various connectivity options on a MIDI keyboard controller, helping readers understand their importance in music production setups

Connectivity is essential for getting MIDI data to and from the keyboard into your computer or MIDI hardware.

USB for Plug-and-Play Computer Connection

Most keyboards today at minimum have a USB port which provides power to the unit while also transmitting MIDI messages.

USB is convenient since you can simply connect to your computer without needing a separate power adapter.

Traditional MIDI Ports for Hardware Compatibility

However, some keyboards also provide traditional 5-pin DIN MIDI ports for compatibility with MIDI interface devices and older MIDI gear.

This allows you to control external sound modules and sync timing with drum machines and sequencers from the 80s and 90s before USB adoption.

Wireless Bluetooth MIDI for Cable-Free Operation

Additionally, Bluetooth MIDI eliminates cable clutter for a wireless setup.

This gives you freedom to move around with the keyboard and integrate with tablets or smartphones wirelessly.

A few higher-end keyboards also have standard 1/4″ audio outputs to directly connect studio monitors or an amp for instant sound without a computer.

Consider both your current gear setup and future needs when evaluating connectivity.

USB along with 5-pin MIDI and Bluetooth provides maximum flexibility for controlling software, interfacing with MIDI hardware, and wireless mobility.

Should Software Bundles Factor Into My Decision?

Image depicting a MIDI keyboard controller with software bundles, highlighting their significance in the decision-making process for musicians

Many MIDI keyboard manufacturers partner with software companies to bundle slimmed down or “light” versions of popular DAWs and virtual instruments.

These may include starters editions of Ableton Live, FL Studio, Logic Pro, Garageband and virtual synths like Arturia’s Analog Lab Lite, Native Instruments Komplete Start, or Melodics lessons.

This can provide an appealing push for new producers, offering a taste of popular music software to start recording and making beats right away.

However, the included software should not be the primary driver in your buying decision.

The DAWs are usually stripped down from their full versions, with limited tracks, recording time, effects, virtual instruments, and options.

The “lite” synths typically only provide 10-30 presets rather than the full library.

These entry-level editions are great for getting started, but you’ll likely want to upgrade to full versions down the road if you get serious about production.

Focus on Keyboard Features First

Rather than bundles, focus first on the keyboard’s core features – key size and feel, controls, connectivity options, etc.

Those physical traits integrate seamlessly with any music software rather than being locked into a single eco-system.

View Bundles as Bonuses, Not Deciding Factors

So seek bundles secondarily – take advantage of any included software, but don’t let it outweigh factors like playability, controls, and connectivity that enable you to grow over time.

How Portable Should My MIDI Keyboard Be?

Image illustrating various MIDI keyboard controllers with different levels of portability, assisting readers in making choices based on their specific needs

Portability should be a prime consideration if you’ll need to transport your keyboard between home, studio, gig, or band practice locations.

Super Portable Mini Keyboards

Stage pianos and mini 25- to 49-key models are designed explicitly for portability, with light weight around 5-10 pounds and slim form factors that fit into backpacks or tote bags.

Some come with custom carrying cases or backpacks for easy, protected transport.

Full-Size Keyboards Can Still Be Moved

Full-size 61- to 88-key home keyboards are naturally bulkier and heavier, weighing 15 pounds or more.

But some provide lightweight synth action keys and optional keyboard stands with folding legs to enhance portability.

Look for models around 12-15 pounds if you need to move it frequently.

Though if it will mostly reside in your studio, a heavier unit shouldn’t be an issue.

Consider how and where you intend to use the keyboard.

Seated use at home allows larger keyboards, while frequent transport calls for more compact mobile models.

But know that many full-size keyboards can be moved with proper cases and some elbow grease.

Prioritize keys and controls first, then choose the most portable form factor for your needs.

What Is A Realistic Budget For A Home MIDI Keyboard?

Image illustrating a range of MIDI keyboard controllers at different price points, assisting readers in understanding budget considerations for their home setups

Home MIDI keyboard prices cover a wide range from around $100 on the low end up to over $1000 for pro-level controllers.

In general, more keys, better key action, premium controls, and features will mean a higher price tag.

But excellent options exist for any budget level.

Capable MIDI Controllers for $200-$500

As a baseline, you can find very capable MIDI controllers in the $200 to $500 range from brands like Akai, M-Audio, Novation and Native Instruments.

Entry Level Under $100

For those just starting out, mini 25-key models around $100 provide an excellent entry point with decent key feel and basic controls to begin exploring MIDI recording and virtual instruments.

The ultra-budget end under $100 may compromise too much on key feel and controls.

High End $700-$1500+

On the high end, 88-key weighted hammer keyboards with premium controls and features can run $700 to $1500+.

The key is determining your must-have priorities like key feel, controls, connectivity, mobility needs, etc.

Make your wish list, then find the keyboard that best ticks those boxes at a price matching your budget.

Don’t feel like you need to spend a fortune to start making music at home.

With some research, focus, and realistic expectations at your price tier, you’ll find an ideal MIDI controller keyboard for your needs and goals.

Conclusion

Purchasing a MIDI keyboard can seem overwhelming at first with so many options to consider – key size, action, controls, connectivity, bundles, portability, and budget.

But by taking the time to reflect on your needs as a musician and producer, you can zero in on the perfect controller to unlock your creativity.

Focus on the key feel, controls, and connectivity features that will enable natural musical expression.

Prioritize weighted hammer action if you want an authentic piano playing experience, or synth action for speed and flexibility.

And choose a keyboard with the pads, knobs, wheels, and connectivity to integrate seamlessly with your studio gear and workflow.

With some thoughtful research guided by your needs and budget, you’ll find the ideal MIDI keyboard to become an extension of your musical ideas and take your productions to the next level.

Dominic

Dominic is the chief editor of the Burton Acoustix blog which writes about acoustics and soundproofing to help readers with their queries and questions they might have with regard to improving any sound or noise issues that they faced in their life.